Hookless rims: safety rationale and marketing

In this episode of the Velo podcast, we're doing some collective venting about the stuff that grinds our gears, but we don’t start there. Instead, we open with some breaking news from Lisa about Ironman of all things. We don't usually spend much time on triathlons, but this is less about the sport and more about the corporation that controls it. We have to ask: Is a new gear ban with a "safety" justification actually just a thin veil for a commercial cash grab?

From there, we pivot to the two years I’ve spent living with the Garmin Edge 1050. The "fancy walled garden" of the Garmin ecosystem creates a trap that’s hard to escape, but is the tech actually enough to keep anyone there? I think it is, but I also made a big mistake with my initial read on the 1050 when it launched, and it’s time I owned up to it.

Then, the episode shifts into a rapid-fire round of industry complaints:

Mike kicks things off by explaining why a "standard" designed to fix creaking has actually created a new nightmare for home mechanics. We mostly agree on this one, but we want to know if you’ve felt the same pain in your workshop.

Then it’s my turn to rant about unwritten rules. I dig into why I never quite seem to fit in on the local ride, while Lisa offers some perspective, then firmly lays down the real rules of engagement.

Rules established, we jump back to Mike’s crusade against electric mini pumps. We’re all in agreement that they're a bit silly, but Mike shocks us with an unexpected admission about a different strategy he actually endorses. There’s a brief mention of hookless here, too, but I let it go... for now.

Lisa gets surprisingly fired up about the "rules" of jersey pockets, and Mike has his own gears to grind here regarding bibs. Lisa starts with a strong point, and we think she's on to something, but she loses us after Mike swoops in with his own complaint about bibs.

Mike gets on his high horse to explain why your gravel bike shouldn't just be a road bike with fat tires and how current designs make descents scarier than they need to be. I eventually force him to admit he’s wrong, and I may have done a small victory dance off-camera.

My victory doesn't last long. To close things out, I get on my own high horse to talk hookless. We get into a heated discussion about why hookless even exists and whether "mini-hooks" are a real solution or just more marketing. I’ll call it like it is: I think the public is falling for the marketing BS, but maybe you think I’m the one who’s wrong?

Let us know in the comments where you think I’m off my rocker and where Lisa and Mike are spot on. Or, if there’s something else driving you crazy in the bike world that we missed, tell us about it.

00:00 – Episode Intro and "Things that Grind our Gears"

00:57 – Breaking News: Ironman Corporation bans athlete video equipment

07:40 – Garmin Edge 1050: A two-year long-term review and the ecosystem trap

38:20 – Things that grind our gears: Mike hates T47 bottom brackets

42:32 – Things that grind our gears: Josh hates group rides

45:29 – Things that grind our gears: Lisa hates stopping at the top of the climb

46:56 – Things that grind our gears: Everyone hates electric mini pumps

53:34 – Things that grind our gears: Lisa hates bad jersey pockets

54:21 – Things that grind our gears: Mike hates bibs without pockets

56:16 – Things that grind our gears: Mike hates gravel bike geometry

01:07:58 – Things that grind our gears: A heated debate over Hookless Rims