The Controversy Over the Death of Umar Ali Al-Lahu Anhu

According to the non-sundni groups the shiya groups the Prophet Salaam explicitly intended to write the walsiyya for aliyy ibn al-Abut al-Bud. Ibn Abbas is saying the biggest calamity the calamity of Thursday was the fact that Umar did not get to write down that al-Ili should have been the Khalifa. Our scholars have interpreted this in many different ways and I spent a good amount of time today going over like at least seven eight different classical scholars so we'll go over these opinions very briefly Imam al-Hatabi one of the early scholars of Islam died 388 Hidra he said that we cannot understand that