American: Basic Economy No Longer Earns

Which U.S. airline loyalty program delivers the most value in 2026? In this roundtable discussion, the 10xTravel crew debates Alaska Airlines, United MileagePlus, and American AAdvantage to determine which program stands out for earning miles, redeeming points, elite status perks, and partner networks.

Travis, Emily, and Matt each defend one airline program, breaking down recent changes, hidden strengths, and real world tradeoffs travelers need to understand before committing their loyalty. This episode is designed to help you rethink how airline programs actually work in 2026 and whether chasing status still makes sense.

You’ll hear the crew's perspectives on:

• Which airline miles are easiest to earn in 2026
• How redemption value really compares across Alaska, United, and American
• Whether elite status still delivers meaningful benefits
• How alliances and partners affect award availability
• Why some loyalty strategies may no longer be worth the effort

Tune in to learn which which program may work best for how you travel in 2026!

Timestamps:

0:00 Intro: Best Airline Loyalty Program for 2026

01:15 Roundtable Format & Airlines Chosen (Alaska, United, American)

04:10 Icebreaker: Best Airport Lounge Snacks

10:55 How We’re Judging Each Program

11:20 Earning Points: Alaska's Atmos Rewards

16:05 Alaska Credit Cards & “Choose Your Own Adventure” Earning

21:00 Earning Points: United MileagePlus

23:45 United Credit Cards & Star Alliance Earning

31:00 Earning Points: American Airlines AAdvantage

33:30 Earning & Redeeming Points: United & Star Alliance

38:40 United Devaluations & Partner Award Changes

42:55 Redeeming Points: American Airlines Sweet Spots

44:40 Alaska Stopovers & Unique Partner Value

48:10 Elite Status Evaluations

01:05:30 Which Program Is Best for the Average Traveler?

01:08:10 Final Votes & Why American Wins

01:11:00 Why Delta Was Not Included

01:14:30 Listener Spotlight: Family United Redemption to Aruba

01:17:20 Final Thoughts

Links and Resources from this Episode:

Take Our Free Points and Miles Course

New To Points and Miles? Listen to Episodes 1-6 of the podcast

Our Best Credit Cards List (Updated Monthly)

My10x: Manage your points and miles in one place

Let us book your next award flight for you

Upgrade your next stay with our Luxury Hotel Program

Get free, personalized advice on choosing your next card

10xTravel+: Upgrade your travel by becoming a member today

Join us at an upcoming Meetup

Stay Connected:
Join our Community: 10xTravel Insiders
Follow us on Instagram: @10xTravelblog
Watch this and every episode of Takeoff on YouTube: @10xTravel
Subscribe for more tips on travel, points, and miles! Don’t forget to hit the notification bell so you never miss an episode.

Advertiser Disclosure: Some of the card links and other products that appear on this website are from companies which 10xTravel will earn an affiliate commission. 10xTravel is part of an affiliate sales network and receives compensation for sending traffic to partner sites, such as CreditCards.com. The content in this video is accurate as of the posting date. Some of the offers mentioned may no longer be available.