Performance management is broken

Check out this episode of the #1 people analytics podcast with special guest, Buddy Benge, Head of Workforce Strategy and Resource Management at Edward Jones!

In this wide-ranging, unfiltered, and deeply thought-provoking conversation, Buddy joins host Cole Napper to explore the real future of work—beyond the buzzwords, vendor hype, and recycled HR talking points. Buddy shares his unconventional journey from coding AOL text-based games at 18 to earning a master’s degree from Cornell and building early dashboards at Raytheon, where he helped shape strategic workforce planning. He later stood up people analytics functions at Monsanto and Bayer and led Human Capital Insights at Edward Jones before stepping into his current role defining workforce strategy and resource management for a 55,000+ associate financial services firm. Together, Cole and Buddy unpack what workforce strategy actually means inside a large, complex organization. They explore how AI, automation, sourcing strategy, process excellence, job architecture, FP&A, and upskilling converge in a modern future-of-work function. Buddy explains why the conversation must shift from static “roles” to the “work to be done,” and how organizations need to deconstruct tasks, redesign jobs, and rethink capability building to remain competitive in an AI-accelerated world. The episode doesn’t shy away from controversy. Buddy challenges assumptions about AI agents, probabilistic versus deterministic systems, and unrealistic expectations placed on emerging technologies. He breaks down the math behind multi-step automation error rates and why leaders must understand acceptable risk, system maturity, and economic tradeoffs before turning decision-making over to machines. From there, the conversation expands into bold critiques of HR itself. Buddy questions why HR technology is often misconfigured and underleveraged, why performance management frequently destroys more value than it creates, and why common talent acquisition metrics like quality of hire may be fundamentally flawed. He pushes listeners to rethink how value is defined in white-collar work, how compensation systems attempt to price roles without understanding task-level impact, and why we may lack a shared language for articulating real contribution. They also explore leadership development, coaching, employee listening, benefits strategy, retirement risk, relocation in a return-to-office era, and the evolution of HR job titles. Buddy argues that leadership development may be the single most important function inside an organization—and that its future could be significantly reshaped by AI-driven tools. Throughout the episode, two seasoned practitioners wrestle with the tension between legacy HR structures and the urgent need to evolve. This is not a surface-level trends conversation. It is a candid, systems-level discussion about analytics maturity, data life cycles, organizational design, and the practical realities of driving change inside complex institutions. If you care about workforce intelligence, analytics, AI disruption, and the structural future of HR, this episode delivers sharp, experience-driven insight from someone who has built and reinvented people analytics functions across global organizations. If you like this episode, you’d also love exploring prior episodes—visit colenapper.com for the full archive and show links.