Why Oil Stayed Elevated Despite Ceasefire Signals

In Episode 181 of Facts vs Feelings, Ryan Detrick, Chief Market Strategist at Carson Group, and Sonu Varghese, Chief Macro Strategist at Carson Group, dig into one of the most consequential geopolitical developments in recent memory, the ongoing Strait of Hormuz crisis, and what it means for oil markets, global supply chains, and your portfolio.

They break down what it would mean if the U.S. exits the conflict without reopening the strait, why Iran could emerge as a de facto regional hegemon, and how a potential toll system on tanker traffic could reshape global energy economics. They also explore why crude oil remains stubbornly elevated despite ceasefire signals, the growing "air pocket" in global oil supply as floating storage drains, and the long term instability risks including nuclear proliferation that could keep an ongoing risk premium baked into energy prices.

On the markets side, Ryan and Sonu make the case that this pullback is unlike any bear market on record, with the S&P 500 taking an unusually long time to reach even a 5% decline from its peak. They walk through why the year to date drawdown is almost entirely explained by multiple contraction and not deteriorating earnings, and how forward EPS and profit margins continue to hit new highs even as headlines stay grim. The duo also examine the dramatic drawdowns in mega cap tech names, why the market may be pricing in a recession that isn't materializing, and why diversification across sectors, styles, and geographies is paying off in ways many investors haven't seen in years.

The episode wraps with a Disney and Universal trip report, Sonu's allergy update, Ryan's eye health journey, and a big congratulations to his daughter Susanna on her college commitment to Penn State.

Key Takeaways:

• Trump withdrawing without reopening the strait could establish Iran as the dominant regional power
• A tanker toll system could generate $100B+ annually for Iran, reshaping Middle East geopolitics
• The S&P 500 decline is 100% multiple contraction; earnings and margins remain strong tailwinds
• Forward 12 month EPS is up 7% in Q1 alone, with half of that gain coming during the crisis
• No bear market since WWII has started with such a slow initial 5% decline, a historically unusual pattern
• Mega cap tech stocks are down 22 to 35% from highs, pricing in a recession that hasn't arrived
• Diversification across value, international, commodities, and small caps is quietly working

Jump to:

0:00 – Welcome and the Great Kit Kat Heist 

2:10 – Trump's Potential Pullback and Hormuz Control 

5:50 – Iran's Toll Scenario and Global Leverage 

9:10 – Why Oil Stays Elevated Despite Peace Signals 

11:55 – Energy as a Strategic Hedge Trade 

16:10 – Hedging Activity and Encouraging Market Breadth 

18:45 – Tanker Traffic Slowdown and Supply Time Lags 

22:05 – Floating Storage Drawdown Explained 

35:23 – Mega Cap Tech Drawdowns and Recession Pricing 

41:10 – Slow Burn Selloff and What the VIX Is Telling Us 

48:05 – Diversification Lessons From Lost Decades 

56:50 – Final Thoughts and Listener Requests

Connect with Ryan:

• LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/ryandetrick/

• X: https://x.com/RyanDetrick

Connect with Sonu:

• LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/sonu-varghese-phd/

• X: https://x.com/sonusvarghese?lang=en

Questions about the show? We’d love to hear from you! factsvsfeelings@carsongroup.com