Why write 'libertarians told you so'?

Chuck Todd unpacks the fallout from Trump's State of the Union address and previews what's shaping up to be a pivotal primary season. He argues that the speech wasn't designed to be coherent — it was engineered for social media moments and base solidification, with Trump drafting off the popularity of others like the Olympic hockey team rather than making a case to swing voters, and echoing Biden's mistake of trying to sell a country that doesn't feel it on the economy. He breaks down the JD Vance "fraud czar" announcement and the immediate move to suspend Medicaid funding to Minnesota as classic base-juicing, then pivots to a sharp analysis of the Iran standoff: Trump's base won't tolerate a prolonged war but might accept limited strikes, Iran knows this and could rope-a-dope the administration, and you can't air strike your way to regime change. He argues that Cuba on the brink of societal collapse with Cuban Americans eager to help rebuild — represents a far easier foreign policy win that Trump is inexplicably ignoring. He then turns to the Texas primaries, where Cornyn has trailed Paxton in every poll and likely can't win without a Trump endorsement, while the Crockett-Talarico Democratic race is showing Clinton-Sanders demographic splits with Crockett leading among groups more likely to actually vote. He notes that many of Chuck Schumer's recruited candidates nationally are already losing, and that the establishment is deeply unpopular this cycle — with a new poll showing insurgent Graham Platner crushing Janet Mills by 40 points as further proof that 2026 is shaping up as an anti-establishment wave.

Katherine Mangu-Ward — editor-in-chief of Reason magazine and author of the viral New York Times op-ed "Libertarians: We Told You So" — joins the Chuck Toddcast for a sharp, wide-ranging conversation about what the libertarian moment looks like when executive power has run amok. She opens with a disarming observation: Americans tend to discover their inner libertarian whenever they dislike the president — and notes that a version of her op-ed could have been written under Biden too. But the Trump era, she argues, has vindicated libertarian warnings in ways that should alarm everyone: warrantless ICE entries that have silenced the very conservatives who once championed the Fourth Amendment, tech CEO congressional hearings that were really about locking in corporate access to state power, and a cronyism so brazen it has paradoxically made citizens hate corporations more than the government enabling them. 

The conversation takes a fascinating turn into policy territory rarely explored on political podcasts. Mangu-Ward engages seriously with the question of whether there's a libertarian case for nationalized healthcare. They also tackle Trump turning Democrats into free-trade activists, the risks of economic nationalism, why demands for safety net cuts fall far short of solving the budget problem, and the fine line between prediction markets and sportsbooks. Looking ahead to 2026, Mangu-Ward points to Arizona — a state that has always produced what she calls "mutant strains" of libertarianism — as the place to watch for whether libertarian-leaning candidates can finally break through at the ballot box.

Finally, he answers listeners’ questions in the “Ask Chuck” segment and explains his beef with the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame.

Go to  https://zbiotics.com/CHUCKTODDCAST and use CHUCKTODDCAST at checkout for 15% off any first time orders of ZBiotics probiotics.”

Protect your family with life insurance from Ethos. Get up to $3 million in coverage in as little as 10 minutes at https://ethos.com/chuck. Application times may vary. Rates may vary.

Thank you Wildgrain for sponsoring. Visit http://wildgrain.com/TODDCAST and use the code "TODDCAST" at checkout to receive $30 off your first box PLUS free Croissants for life!

Link in bio or go to https://getsoul.com & enter code TODDCAST for 30% off your first order.

American Finance Disclaimer: NMLS 182334, nmlsconsumeraccess.org. APR for rates in the 5s start at 6.196% for well qualified borrowers. Call 866-885-1081, for details about credit costs and terms. Or https://apply.americanfinancing.net/thechucktoddcast

Timeline:

(Timestamps may vary based on advertisements)

00:00 Chuck Todd’s introduction

04:00 Initial fallout from Trump’s State of the Union speech

05:45 Trump’s focus is to solidify his base, not reach swing voters

07:00 Speech wasn’t coherent, it was meant for social media moments

07:45 Trump tried to draft on the popularity of others during speech

08:30 Like Biden, Trump tried to sell the country that the economy is working

10:30 Trump announced JD Vance as “fraud czar”

11:15 Vance announces they’ll suspend Medicaid funding to Minnesota

12:15 Trump isn’t politically nimble, but knows how to juice the base

13:15 Trump’s speech only played one note to his base

15:30 It’s tough to understand what Trump is up to with Iran

16:15 Trump’s base won’t accept a prolonged war with Iran, just limited strikes

17:00 Iran knows Trump’s base isn’t on board, could rope-a-dope him

18:45 You can’t air strike your way to regime change… so what’s the plan?

20:00 25% chance of regime change, 25% chance it strengthens regime

21:15 Trump’s impatience is one of his worst political instincts

22:15 Cuba is on the brink of societal/regime collapse

23:00 Cuban Americans would jump at opportunity to rebuild Cuba

24:15 Cuba is a much easier potential foreign policy victory for Trump

25:30 War with Iran could be a massive resource drain on the U.S. 

26:00 Primary season about to kick off, starting with Texas

26:30 What happens in Dem primary, will affect GOP runoff

27:15 Cornyn has trailed Paxton in every poll

28:30 Cornyn can’t win without Trump’s endorsement

30:15 Divide between Talarico and Crockett has been fascinating

30:45 Bernie Sanders & AOC have stayed out of Texas primary

32:00 If 3rd candidate gets over 3 points, real chance of Dem runoff

33:00 Polling for Talarico/Crockett shows similar splits to Clinton/Sanders

33:45 Crockett ahead with demographic groups more likely to vote

35:00 Talarico is trying to tout his electability in the general

36:00 It’s hard to know whether Talarico or Crockett is more electable

39:00 If Talarico wins, it might force Trump off the fence & to back Cornyn

40:30 It will be hard for Dems to win in Texas, but it will be competitive

41:15 Many people are betting Talarico will be the next Pete Buttigieg

42:15 New poll shows Graham Platner beating Janet Mills by 40 points

44:00 Many candidates Chuck Schumer recruited are losing

45:15 The establishment is deeply unpopular this year

54:30 Katherine Mangu-Ward joins the Chuck ToddCast

55:30 We’re all more libertarian when we don’t like the president

56:15 Motivation for writing NYT op-ed “Libertarians: We Told You So”

58:00 Libertarian has been typically conservative in western U.S.

59:00 Kentucky has been sending most libertarians to congress

1:00:00 Different version of Op-ed could have been written under Biden

1:01:45 American elections recently haven’t given anyone a mandate

1:03:00 Supreme Court begged congress to do their job in tariff decision

1:04:30 Where are the conservatives now that warrantless entries are happening?

1:06:00 Trump has bullied out libertarians and unsupportive Republicans

1:08:15 Biggest worries about big tech are worries about the state

1:09:45 Don’t want big tech to enable state actions against individual rights

1:11:45 We might need a cultural sea change for congress to rein in big tech

1:13:15 Trump’s cronyism has made citizens hate only corporations, not government

1:14:00 Less government reduces opportunity for cronyism

1:16:00 Tech CEO hearings were CEOs trying to lock in their place

1:17:00 Market discipline does seem to be working in the AI space

1:18:30 Where is some government regulation acceptable for libertarians?

1:20:30 Trump has turned Democrats into free-trade activists

1:22:00 The risks of economic nationalism

1:24:30 Where do libertarians draw the line on the social safety net?

1:25:15 Demands for safety net cuts fall very short of solving budget problem

1:27:00 Student loan debt forgiveness would benefit higher earners

1:28:30 More people want government to have a larger role

1:30:45 Is there a libertarian argument for nationalized healthcare?

1:32:45 Regulation in healthcare & childcare have exploded costs

1:35:00 Market forces haven’t worked in healthcare pricing

1:36:30 We’re being lied to about pricing practices in healthcare

1:37:45 Should insurance be able to price based on preexisting conditions?

1:39:30 Catastrophic coverage is basically illegal now

1:40:45 We should just pay out of pocket for small, regular procedures

1:42:15 Charity or government subsidies should assist preexisting conditions

1:45:00 How would a libertarian clean up the prediction markets?

1:47:30 Not a major difference between prediction markets & sportsbooks

1:50:00 Will libertarians have a moment at the ballot box in 2026?

1:50:45 Arizona has always produced mutant strains of libertarian

1:54:00 Arizona has always been libertarian socially & economically

1:55:30 It’d be interesting to hear a libertarian proposal for healthcare

1:56:00 Ask Chuck

1:56:15 Will Republicans divert focus from anti-trans rhetoric to the economy?

1:59:00 Trump’s three part strategy to State of the Union?

2:02:45 Does America’s GDP actually translate to a higher standard of living?

2:05:30 How can Florida's government function without property tax?

2:09:30 After the TX & NC primaries, will GOP candidates distance from Trump?

2:12:45 Thoughts on the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.