Worst Redemptions: Early Portal Mistakes

Episode 164 of the Award Travel 101 podcast features host Mike Zaccheo with guests Tim Kozikowski and Mary Willet, a New Jersey–based couple who are both deeply involved in the points-and-miles hobby. The episode begins with a community question about whether beginners should focus on earning Chase or Amex points. The discussion highlights that most experienced travelers recommend earning both. Chase is often preferred for valuable transfer partners like Hyatt and United, particularly for travelers based near United hubs or those still under the Chase 5/24 rule. Amex is favored for its strong everyday earning rates, especially with cards like the Amex Gold, and for strong airfare redemption opportunities. The broader takeaway from the community discussion is that sign-up bonuses provide the most value, and diversification across programs—sometimes including Capital One and Citi—is generally the best strategy.

The hosts also cover recent travel news, including new offers on Marriott Bonvoy credit cards and an improvement allowing members to top off Marriott free night certificates by up to 25,000 points instead of the previous 15,000 limit. Another update highlights the opening of the Hyatt Regency Niagara Falls Fallsview on the Canadian side of Niagara Falls, offering new redemption opportunities with strong room views and potential suite upgrade awards. After sharing upcoming travel plans—such as trips to Texas, Thailand, Japan, and community meetups—the conversation shifts to the main topic: how couples manage a “P1/P1” relationship where both partners actively participate in the award travel hobby rather than one person doing all the planning.

Tim and Mary discuss how they each got into the hobby, starting with an Aeroplan credit card in 2022, and how their shared interest shapes their travel strategy. They talk about coordinating credit card applications, managing points balances, dividing responsibilities like spreadsheets and bookings, and occasionally navigating disagreements over points strategy. The episode highlights how collaboration can improve optimization, from staggering applications around rules like 5/24 to pursuing different loyalty programs or business cards. The hosts wrap up with redemption stories, lessons from mistakes, rapid-fire travel preferences, and advice for couples entering the hobby—emphasizing communication, organization, and having clear travel goals while enjoying the experiences points make possible.

Episode Links:

• Marriott Bonvoy Card offers
• Marriott Now Allowing Top offs up to 25k
• Hyatt Regency Niagara Falls Fallsview

Where to Find Us

1. The Award Travel 101 Facebook Community.
2. To book time with our team, check out Award Travel 1-on-1.
3. You can also email us at 101@award.travel
4. Buy your Award Travel 101 Merch here
5. Reserve tickets to our Spring 2026 Meetup in Phoenix now. award.travel/phx2026

Our partner CardPointers helps us get the most from our cards. Signup today at https://cardpointers.com/at101 for a 30% discount on annual and lifetime subscriptions!

Lastly, we appreciate your support of the AT101 Podcast/Community when you signup for your next card!

Technical note: Some user experience difficulty streaming the podcast while connected to a VPN. If you have difficulty, disconnect from your VPN.