9/11 erased his paper fortune

Matt O’Hayer recalls watching the attacks in New York, laying off staff immediately, and seeing his company value collapse overnight.

Play episode from 22:52

chevron_right

Transcript

chevron_right

Transcript

Episode notes

For decades, a dozen eggs was just… a dozen eggs.

No story. No real branding. No reason to care who produced them.

Then Matt O’Hayer came along and asked a question almost nobody in America was asking: what if store-bought eggs could be different? What if they tasted better, looked better, and came from hens raised in a much more humane way?

The business he launched– with 20 hens and some used trailers– is now the number-one pasture-raised egg producer in the US, with a network of 600 farms, and a projected revenue of nearly $1B this year.

When he started Vital Farms, Matt was in his 50s, living in an RV on the farm, and trying to convince people to pay premium prices for eggs.

Before that, his passion for business drove him to pursue an astonishing range of ideas: carpet-cleaning, a barter-exchange franchise, a stint as a charter-boat captain and broker. One of his businesses left him nearly broke after 9-11, and there were many other hard lessons along the way.

This is a story about metabolizing failure into success, and turning one of the most overlooked shelves in the grocery store… into a billion dollar opportunity.

What you’ll learn:

The hard lessons Matt learned from 3 (+) decades of founding businesses
How 9/11 changed his life
What 4 years as a boat captain taught him about leading–and serving
How “conscious capitalism” became the blueprint for Vital Farms
Why pasture-raised eggs were a branding opportunity hiding in plain sight
How Whole Foods became an early and critical partner
Why great products grow faster when customers do your work for you

Timestamps:

07:48 – “I didn’t have 300 dollars.” Matt starts a carpet-cleaning company with no real plan
11:31 – The barter business that taught Matt how to scale complex ideas
17:58 – Building a travel company, taking it public, and growing it to roughly $50 million in sales
22:57 – The morning of 9/11: Matt watches his business collapse in real time
25:59 – Starting over, Matt becomes a charter boat captain –plus chef, teacher, and toilet-fixer
31:16 – The blog essay that transformed how Matt thought about business
34:19 – The lightbulb conversation: pasture-raised eggs could become a real company
41:03 – Starting the farm in Austin: “I bought a thousand baby chicks.”
43:58 – The first eggs taste great, but nobody wants to pay for them
49:53 – Finally: The first Whole Foods pallet
50:52 – A label mistake gets Vital Farms pulled from shelves
1:03:09 – How the egg carton became one of Vital Farms’ most powerful branding tools
1:08:24 – Why humane eggs cost more—and why Matt believes they should

This episode was produced by Kerry Thompson, with music by Ramtin Arablouei.

Edited by Neva Grant, with research help from Casey Herman.

—-----------------

Follow How I Built This:

Instagram → @howibuiltthis

X → @HowIBuiltThis

Facebook → How I Built This

Follow Guy Raz:

Instagram → @guy.raz

Youtube → guy_raz

X → @guyraz

Substack → guyraz.substack.com