#299: What Nobody Tells You About Publishing a Book—with Award-Winning Podcaster Eric Zimmer
Creator Science
Intro
Jay introduces Eric Zimmer, the podcast, and announces Eric's new book; episode context and early sponsor read.
Eric Zimmer launched The One You Feed podcast in 2014 with no audience, no name recognition, and a podcast name that took explaining. Twelve years, 850+ episodes, and 500 million downloads later, he released his first book — How a Little Becomes a Lot — a title that is, in every way, the story of his life. In this conversation, we talk about how incremental progress actually works, why you can't see it happening in real time, and why that's actually fine.
We also go deep on the business reality of podcasting in 2026 — the early mover advantage is gone, ad CPMs are harder to sustain, and Eric is actively pivoting from reaching many people loosely to serving fewer people more deeply. Then we spend a lot of time in the weeds of the book publishing process: the six-month proposal, the 18 months of writing in half-day increments, the uncomfortable dance between your vision and what an agent and publisher think will sell, and the emotional work of promotion — watching who shows up and who doesn't, and applying his own frameworks to keep from spiraling. This one got personal. I'm in month 11 of my own book proposal, and Eric helped me see the other side of a process that has genuinely been shaking my confidence.
Full transcript and show notes
***
TIMESTAMPS
(02:54) The One You Feed parable: two wolves, and which one wins
(05:18) How to remember to make the right choice daily (Still Point method)
(07:37) Building a podcast to 850 episodes: the only way is one at a time
(10:14) The hair growth metaphor for creator progress
(11:36) How Eric renews his commitment to the show after 12 years
(13:47) What it means to enter your "happy place" as a podcast host
(17:23) State of podcasting in 2026: early mover advantage is gone
(19:11) Pivoting from ad revenue to deeper relationships with fewer people
(22:38) Why Eric is (mostly) skipping video — and why that's okay
(24:58) The three-person team behind 500 million downloads
(27:45) How Eric knew it was finally time to write a book
(30:24) The writing process: three half-days a week across 18 months
(31:09) The proposal took six months — and ended up looking nothing like Eric's vision
(34:21) Jay opens up: 11 months into his own book proposal
(39:12) Non-negotiables: how to protect the heart of your book
(40:35) Expectations vs. reality of book launch week
(43:01) The emotional work of asking everyone you know for support
(44:47) Why the marketing marathon is harder than the writing
(50:55) How to ask for blurbs — and who says yes (Susan Cain, Charles Duhigg, Young Pueblo)
(55:51) What Eric would do differently for book two
***
RECOMMENDED NEXT EPISODE
→ #163: David Moldawer — Diving deep into book publishing with an industry insider
***
ASK CREATOR SCIENCE
***
WHEN YOU'RE READY
***
CONNECT
***
SPONSORS
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
The AI-powered Podcast Player
