Brainstem Claims and Clinical Skepticism

Get A Full Breakdown Of Your Own Conscious Inner Experience (100% Free): https://www.skool.com/the-giants-shoulder-6526/about

Matthias Michel is an MIT philosopher and co-founder of the MIT Consciousness Club who has developed one of the most provocative theories of consciousness in recent years: Perceptual Reality Monitoring. He argues your brain runs a constant reality check on every signal it receives — deciding what's real and what's noise — and that this mechanism IS consciousness.

Expect to learn how your brain tells the difference between perception, memory, imagination and noise, why conscious vision lags 400 milliseconds behind reality, why every fast action you've ever taken was driven entirely unconsciously, why fish probably have no conscious visual experience at all, how aphantasics may have mental imagery they can't consciously access, why conscious mental imagery might actually be a bug in the system, what blindsight patient GY's experience reveals about unconscious vision, and much more

…

Timestamps:

0:00 Matthias Michel — What Is Perceptual Reality Monitoring?

2:58 How does the brain tell reality from imagination?

5:30 Snake fear in Malaysia: when prediction systems misfire

6:22 Blood vessel shadows and the stuff your brain erases

7:50 Motion-induced blindness: your brain deleting real objects

9:50 Is schizophrenia a broken reality monitor?

11:02 Where does reality monitoring happen in the brain?

12:53 Can you be conscious without a frontal cortex?

15:49 Mark Solms and brainstem consciousness

18:15 What does it mean to see without conscious vision?

18:40 "Tell me what it's like to see behind your head" — blindsight patient GY

20:48 Do fish have conscious vision?

22:05 Why conscious vision is 350-400ms too slow for action

24:07 Two visual systems: one conscious, one not

25:30 The hollow face illusion fools your eyes but not your hand

26:21 Binocular rivalry: your eyes know things you don't

29:24 Sensory horizons: why water limits conscious vision

33:17 Could coral reef fish or octopuses be the exception?

37:31 Are fish complete zombies? (60% confidence)

39:18 Should we still protect fish even if they're unconscious?

42:47 Aphantasia through the lens of reality monitoring

46:00 Why conscious imagery might be a "bug"

48:06 Blank access: using imagery without experiencing it

50:17 What is an unconscious visual representation?

55:54 The strongest counterevidence to unconscious imagery

58:50 Pupil dilation and Joel Pearson's results

1:01:18 How do we falsify unconscious imagery?

1:04:30 The PRM explanation for aphantasia: threshold differences

1:07:50 The future of consciousness and aphantasia research

1:10:29 Vividness is multidimensional — lessons from Russell Hurlburt

1:13:35 Brain imaging limitations and the next breakthrough

...

Email for sponsorship enquiries: evan@thegiantsshoulder.com

GS Episodes Mentioned

Mark Solms — https://youtu.be/nMWaQ1U6dcc

Adam Zeman — https://youtu.be/SgA2up6-Bok

Russell Hurlburt (R1) — https://youtu.be/j0gKl-g3DNg

Russell Hurlburt (R2) — https://youtu.be/TfSuvAJB3JU

Merlin Monzel — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g21AqnSV1X4

Joel Pearson — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_I_7HrWYMQ0

Alfredo Spagna - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k8SBHefDnEk