
Why Anti-Zionism Is Really Just Envy | Ep. 17 with Alana Newhouse
The Jeremy Boreing Show
Machines, Teams, and the Artemis Rescue
Jeremy recalls the Artemis splashdown and the divers' trained camaraderie as an example of creative optimism and teamwork.
Anti-Zionism on the left and the right in America today is a kind of envy — envy of a country that still has permission to define itself, defend itself, and have a future. That's the opening claim Alana Newhouse makes to Jeremy Boreing in this two-hour conversation about Zionism, American identity, and the cultural project of believing in tomorrow.
Jeremy sits down with Alana Newhouse — founder and editor-in-chief of Tablet Magazine, author of the breakout essays "Everything Is Broken," "Brokenness," and "Zionism for Everyone" — for a wide-ranging conversation that uses Israel as a lens for diagnosing what's wrong with America.
They get into culture as a "mixing board" (race is loud in Japan, irrelevant in Israel — every culture calibrates differently); America's twin tethers of capitalism and covenant; the four questions Alana says every country has to be able to answer (are your people happy? do they have babies? can they defend themselves? are they future-oriented?); Tucker Carlson's truth-and-lie about Israel and the black pill industrial complex aimed at demoralizing Americans; the Artemis splashdown, the F-15 weapons officer rescue in Iran, and "what are the machines for?"; Alana's four-bucket framework for any institution (conserve, reform, destroy, build new); why she's drawn to leaders like Modi and Milei but skeptical of Orban and "Make America Great Again"; the original meaning of ethnos (it's not bloodline, it's the music a people make together); why anti-Semitism is a symptom and not a cause; and the fertility hiccup, the Gen X reckoning, and the case that creation itself is an act of optimism.
Not a defense of Israeli policy. Not a brief against the contemporary right. A clinical, hopeful argument that the formula that built Israel — particularism plus pragmatism plus idealism — is exportable, and that the future belongs to whoever shows up to build it.
00:00 Anti-Zionism Is Just Envy
05:14 America's Twin Tethers — Capitalism and Covenant
12:22 The "Mixing Board" — Why Cultures Have to Be Different
25:17 The Zionism Formula and the 4 Questions Every Country Must Answer
31:59 What Tucker Carlson Got Wrong About Israel
36:30 The Black Pill Trap and the Lost Faith in the Moon Landing
45:00 Why Alana Built Tablet — Creation as an Act of Optimism
56:35 The Right's Failure on Social Media (and Why AI Is Next)
1:03:22 The 4 Buckets: Conserve, Reform, Destroy, Build New
1:21:39 When Ethnos Goes Wrong — and Why the Nation-State Still Wins
1:28:11 Modi, Milei, Orban — Looking for Joy in World Leaders
1:34:05 The Artemis Diver and the F-15 Rescue: "What Are the Machines For?"
1:46:09 Anti-Semitism Is a Symptom, Not a Cause
1:49:02 Fertility, Gen X, and the Hiccup We Have to Correct


