How many studies does it take for something to be "settled science"? For trans athletes—who face state bans across the country, which recently reached the Supreme Court—there's hardly any research at all. In this episode, we're digging into what that research actually found, and it's way more complicated than the “fairness” advocates would have you believe. Dr. Blair Hamilton walks us through findings showing that trans people gain some advantages and lose others after transitioning. Champion triathlete Chris Mosier talks about what trans kids actually lose when they're banned from sports—and why the real threats to women's athletics have nothing to do with trans people. Whether you’re against trans athletes competing or you’re just trying to understand why politicians are obsessed with a few dozen athletes, this episode will uncover the nuance in the noise.

00:00:00 - Introduction: Where Support Falls Apart
00:01:20 - How Sports Became the Wedge Issue
00:04:08 - The "Settled Science"
00:10:24 - How Many Trans Athletes Actually Exist
00:13:23 - Can't Win by Losing, Can't Win by Winning
00:15:11 - Why Ban Chess and Darts?
00:16:35 - The Playbook of Using Women's Safety
00:18:00 - Genital Inspections and Racial Targeting
00:19:35 - What's Lost: Community, Belonging, and Identity
00:25:17 - Solutions: Sport-Specific Analysis and Evidence-Based Policy
00:27:06 - Why We Celebrate Some Advantages But Not Others
00:29:11 - Conclusion

More from Blair Hamilton:

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/blair90x/?hl=en
X: https://x.com/BlairH_PhD

Trans 101: Trans Athletes & What the Science Actually Says

Taboo Science

Outro

The AI-powered Podcast Player