Book Review: Open Socrates (Part 1)
Don't Worry About the Vase Podcast
Why Zvi Disagrees With Agnes Callard
Zvi summarizes his strong disagreements with Agnes Callard's Open Socrates and why he wrote a long, critical review.
Another record-breaker for length: this one runs to over three and a half hours of audio. If you’ve found these audio versions of Zvi’s posts useful, please consider becoming a paid subscriber, after subscribing to Zvi first, of course. The support really helps.
The Don’t Worry About the Vase Podcast is a listener-supported podcast. To receive new posts and support the cost of creation, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
* 00:00:00 - Introduction
* 00:04:36 - Editor’s Note
* 00:06:48 - A Difference Of Opinion
* 00:09:39 - An Overview
* 00:09:58 - You Don’t Know Me
* 00:11:01 - Untimely Questions
* 00:15:04 - The Unexamined Life is Worth Living
* 00:20:19 - The Quest For The Unexamined Life
* 00:25:26 - Not Everyone Wants To or Should Philosophize All Day
* 00:28:01 - The Seinfeld Fallacy
* 00:29:59 - Socrates was the Lying GOAT of Hypocritical False Humility
* 00:36:03 - Hearing Voices
* 00:39:00 - Simpsons Ancient Greeks Did It
* 00:42:22 - The Proposed Fourth Option: Socratic Inquiry
* 00:47:37 - No Really The Position is Nothing Else Matters
* 00:51:46 - The War on Wavering and Nebulosity
* 00:59:14 - Living Your Best Life
* 01:03:21 - Introducing the Socratic Method (the real one)
* 01:04:46 - Prove Me Wrong, Kids
* 01:06:30 - Socrates Asserts Wrong Conclusions That Are Wrong
* 01:11:10 - You Can Question Your Beliefs
* 01:20:37 - True Opinions Do Not Only Do Good
* 01:23:42 - Meno Plays the Fool
* 01:27:08 - The Central Magician’s Trick
* 01:28:13 - The Gaslighting of Alcibiades
* 01:41:42 - The Measure of a Fight
* 01:50:50 - The Good Fight
* 01:56:25 - The Curious Case of Euthyphro
* 02:00:45 - You Should Be Sad About That
* 02:06:10 - People Respond To Incentives
* 02:13:38 - Self Versus Other
* 02:15:05 - Socrates Declares Humans Have Unified Minds Free Of Various Biases
* 02:24:05 - Revenge
* 02:40:41 - Legal Systems Very Different From Our Own
* 02:45:49 - Socrates Claims The Just And The Advantageous Are Identical
* 02:56:52 - First Up: Utilitarianism
* 02:59:54 - The Main Rival: Deontology (Kantianism? Stoicism?)
* 03:05:51 - A Trolly Problem
* 03:07:37 - The Third and Correct Option: Virtue Ethics
* 03:16:07 - You Are Not Omniscient
* 03:22:57 - The Hardest Thing In This World Is To Live In It
* 03:29:27 - They Call It Utopia For A Reason
* 03:30:50 - The End… Of Book One
Get full access to DWAtV Podcast at dwatvpodcast.substack.com/subscribe
The AI-powered Podcast Player
