This Time Is Never Different

The market feels expensive. Again. So should you invest or wait for a pullback?

Joe Saul-Sehy brings together a powerhouse roundtable featuring Len Penzo, Paula Pant (Afford Anything), and Greg McFarlane to tackle the question every investor faces when markets hit new highs. The twist? This conversation originally happened in 2016 when the SPY ETF which tracks the S&P 500 was trading at around $190. Today it's near $700. Everyone who waited for the "right time" back then missed massive gains through a pandemic, inflation, and everything else.

The group digs into investing rules that sound simple but get complicated fast. Sell losers quickly and let winners run. But how do you define a loser? Buy low and sell high. But what counts as high? Turn off financial TV noise. But how do you stay informed without getting overwhelmed? They debate whether you need pre-set exit strategies or if long term ownership beats trying to time perfect entries and exits.

The conversation shifts to practical money decisions. Cash versus credit. The group mostly favors credit cards for rewards and dispute protection, but uses cash selectively for tips, travel, and splitting group dinners. They debate the risks of a cashless society, negative interest rates, and what happens when you lose the ability to hold physical money.

Then they tackle one of the toughest money topics. How do you answer kids' hard questions about income, spending priorities, and why you use credit cards? The panel shares candid approaches to money conversations with children that balance honesty with age appropriate information.

What You'll Learn:

• Why waiting for the "right time" to invest often means missing gains

• How to think about investing when markets feel too high

• The difference between selling losers fast and giving good investments time to work

• How to define what counts as a loser versus a temporary dip

• Why turning off financial TV matters more than most people think

• The case for credit cards over cash (rewards, protection, tracking)

• When cash still makes sense despite the convenience of cards

• Risks of a cashless society and negative interest rates

• How to answer kids' tough questions about money without oversharing or lying

• Age appropriate ways to explain income, spending, and credit

This Episode Is For You If:

• Markets feel too high and you're not sure whether to invest

• You've been waiting for a pullback and wondering if you're making a mistake

• You want to hear experienced investors debate real strategies, not just theory

• You're trying to figure out the cash versus credit question

• You need language for talking to your kids about money honestly

Question for You:

Have you ever waited to invest because the market felt too high, and if so, did you regret it? Drop your story in the comments or The Basement Facebook group because this roundtable might shift how you think about timing.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices