The Argument That Hussein Did Not Make Tobacco

Ibn Khaldun: Not one single companion mentioned A'hadith about how horuz is not permissible. It just shows that they, like you said many times, they recognize that this is not horuz. And again, I goes back to it. What I believe is misunderstanding basic things and then building arguments on top of that. This can't be used as an argument anyway. They misunderstood that the hilah for obviously at that time, it was not like nowadays where you go to a country and it's already established. He didn't have control of Kufa, ever dented by the people given by A' hadith or to miss it. So I don